Stop tweeting, start meeting

Stop tweeting, start meeting


Mike Hoffman, Client Partner - New Business and Research at SMRS, shares his disenchantment with Twitter and advises to take your audience to the place that shows them the value of the work they would do for you:

After 10 years and around 70,000 tweets, last week I deactivated my Twitter account. For someone who has averaged 20 tweets every single day since 2008, that was quite a big step and one I had considered many times but then stepped back from. This blog isn’t a navel gazing attempt to rationalise this decision but, rather, a meditation on the limits of social and content-driven engagement as, ultimately, a successful tool for recruitment.

There are two areas where I think Twitter has lost space it once owned and where recruiters need to consider the wider context and the limitations of content to engage with users. And, by implication, social media in general.

One of the biggest disappointments with the state of Twitter, for me, is the loss of the opportunity to engage with people in debate before Godwin’s Law kicks in, or a Twitter thread descends into whataboutery or personal abuse. I still believe the truism that Facebook is where you tell lies to your friends and Twitter is where you tell the truth to strangers. Except where once I felt a network of open communities existed, now there is residual mistrust and suspicion over intent and agency.

Astroturfing, burner accounts, pile-ons and bots have effectively eradicated the possibility of genuine mind-changing debate and reduced everything to an entrenched position without the possibility of de-escalation. And I mean EVERYTHING; until I joined Twitter, I never realised the possibility of a prom dress denying someone’s cultural identity or the anger that can be generated by the most innocuous everyday events. If you’re only trying to use content to drive traction with an audience, you’re just as likely to start a bin fire as a debate, and generate the sort of headlines that trash reputations instead of making them.

The second point is the extent to which Boomers/Gen X’ers think Millennials and Gen Zs are on screen and, therefore, missing out on ‘real’ life connections. As though screen relationships are inherently fake and totally detached from the external world. This leads some recruiters to still think they are just a hot meme away from a healthy pipeline of candidates, like it’s 2010.

In my subjective experience, a large proportion of online engagement is in support of offline pursuits. FOMO is real and the growth of budget invested in experiential marketing is testament to the fact that people like to do things because they are good/fun/exciting and not just to create content to share online. There is a symbiosis in the uses of IG and Snapchat to validate young people’s life events, but without the event, the content doesn’t exist. The Premier League wouldn’t exist without the Sky Sports investment, but the product wouldn’t be real without the crowd experiencing the event and creating the content.

As a researcher here at SMRS, I’ve spent more time than most actually talking with graduates about how they like to engage with brands. And the thing that strikes me most is that the power of face-to-face has not lost its impact. The primacy of that first personal interaction, the interest and care shown by the business, goes far deeper in terms of impression and personal recall even months after the event. This cuts both ways – rather memorably, a high-flying finalist told me of his intention to apply for a Big Four graduate employer right up to the point at which he actually met the company representative at a graduate event.

Telling people what makes you unique is unlikely to cut through completely. You need to make it real. Actually take your audience to the place that shows them the value of the work they would do for you. Because the candidate journey doesn’t end at the offer, it ends at the exit interview. And if you’re not doing all you can to ensure candidates feel what it is like to work for you, that will come sooner rather than later.

Thursday, 30 August 2018

Share this article

Any questions? Any comments?

Your instant reactions to this article can be posted here.

(Showing 1 - 5 of 5)

Adam Gordon Date: Aug 31, 2018

In terms of #recruitment, Twitter's biggest benefit has always been its ability to drive more, better offline engagement as far as I've always thought. So why would you quit Twitter?

Mike Hoffman Date: Aug 31, 2018

Hi Adam My decision to quit twitter was purely a personal one - I'm not advocating clients to quit the platform. Yet. Rather this was a personal musing on the dangers of considering content without the wider context of the platform itself. Personally, I think twitter is in danger of suffering reputational damage by its willingness to tolerate hate speech. Increasingly I wonder whether brands will have to consider that in the future - but that's for another day, another post... Mike

Mark Rice Date: Sep 3, 2018

Interesting. Can you advocate using Twitter (or any social channels) to clients if you don’t value them yourself. And is someone quitting Twitter for personal reasons really a news story?

Marcus Body Date: Sep 7, 2018

I think it's an interesting contribution - both your reasons for personally disengaging, but also what brands might need to consider. For me, Twitter is a great place to shout, but equally a "wild west" where there's little genuine interaction, and a lot of negative behaviours. In old skool terms, it's like using a poster site where you KNOW there's a long track record of vandalism. Doesn't mean brands shouldn't use it, but we shouldn't pretend that it's really a good place to broach anything nuanced, complicated, subtle, or difficult.

Mark Rice Date: Sep 14, 2018

A vandalised poster site? LOL No wonder many recruitment folks and agencies still don't 'get' Twitter or social media after all this time. So if it's not good to 'broach anything nuanced, complicated, subtle, or difficult' - what should you use it for?

  • Latest jobs
  • Find out how to place an ad here Media Job Read more >>